Physical Address

304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124

Are linear (red) switches bad for typing?

If you are the owner of a mechanical keyboard or are considering purchasing one, you are surely aware of how difficult it can be to select the appropriate switches. This is an issue that has generated a great deal of discussion on online forums. It is true that selecting the appropriate switch is a highly subjective process. One of the most widely held beliefs, on the other hand, is that the linear (red) switches are detrimental for typing. What is the motivation behind such a statement?

When it comes to typing, linear switches (in red) are not the ideal option. They perform far better in games. Because the time of button actuation is not evident with linear switches, we tend to press the button all the way down without realizing it. This increases the distance that must be traversed, which has a detrimental impact on the pace with which the writing is completed. Additionally, due to the modest pressure required for activation, it is more likely that a button may be unintentionally pressed and a typo will be entered. However, they do have one significant advantage when it comes to writing, and that is that it is a more quiet form of labor. Blue switches, on the other hand, are more ideal for work in an office environment, for example.

In my professional life, I work as a programmer, and in my spare time, I write a blog. As a result, I spend at least half of my waking hours in front of a computer screen. During my exploration into mechanical keyboards, I have previously experimented with a variety of switches that have varying operating properties. In my opinion, the selection of switches is a very personal affair that may be influenced by subjective preferences. Writing on linear switches, on the other hand, looks to be a bit more difficult, based on my personal experience.

Why red switches are bad for typing?

Each switch has an own operating culture that distinguishes it from the others. There is a distinct actuation of the button in the blue and brown switches, respectively. Slowly pressing down on one of the keys, you should be able to feel the instant the key is activated. In the case of the blue button, you will also hear a distinctive click as you press it.

Many people believe that linear switches are more difficult to write than other types of switches since they have completely distinct operating properties. They work in a linear form, as implied by the name of the system. This indicates that the resistance remains constant over the entire button, and we are unable to determine when the button was activated.

To make it work, we don’t have to press the button all the way down, which is theoretically possible. Then, because blue and brown switches can detect such a moment, we may shorten the journey down to the button as well as the time it takes to return to the button. Just make sure you don’t jam it all the way in. As a result, we should be able to compose it more quickly.

This is also conceivable in linear switches, albeit it is more difficult to accomplish. The fact that the time of activation of the button is unnoticeable leads us to press the button all the way in most cases.

However, it is not my place to judge the effectiveness of a certain strategy. I’ve never been able to type at this speed before… Despite the fact that I utilise brown switches on a daily basis, I continue to press the buttons all the way.

The fact that linear (red) switches are “faster” speaks volumes for me when it comes to the argument that they are “worse” for typing. This means that they are much more convenient to press than before. You don’t need to use as much force as you would with blue switches in this situation. This is a significant edge in games since it helps us to react more quickly. When typing, on the other hand, it may result in more unintentional clicks and errors.

Which switches are a better choice for typing?

The blue or brown switches, as previously said, will be the most popular if typing is the primary reason for which we intend to use the keyboard, as this is the most common application. It is not a haphazard selection.

When we look at the activation moments of both types of switches, we can clearly see that they are distinct. The biggest distinction between them is the volume of their respective works. The blue ones generate a distinctive clicking sound, which increases their volume significantly. Some individuals adore this sound, while others despise it.

Personally, I enjoy the sound of this keyboard, however I would not risk bringing such a keyboard to work with me. This distinctive clicking noise can be both annoying and distracting. I prefer to listen to music through my headphones rather than typing on the keyboard on some days. I understand that this comment may come as a surprise to many mechanical keyboard enthusiasts.

As a result, I have chosen brown switches for the keyboard that I use on a regular basis for my professional duties. In their situation, the exact instant when the button was pressed may still be discerned. It is simply this characteristic clicking sound that we eliminate. It turned out that the brown switches were the finest compromise in my opinion.

When linear switches are good choice for typing?

Some switches (especially the blue ones) can be extremely noisy, so be careful when using them. Some folks are extremely upset by this noise……

Depending on whether we require a keyboard that is more “office-friendly” or whether we do not want our families to kick us out of the house because we are unable to sleep at night, linear switches may be the ideal option. Depending on how important volume of work is to us and how concerned we are about the uniqueness of the operation of linear switches, they may turn out to be a winning combination for us. They are simply the most peaceful.

YouTubers and live streamers frequently choose to get a keyboard with linear buttons as well. Because they don’t want the keyboard’s sound to be audible through the microphone, they have it set to muffled.

Which linear switches will be better for typing?

I previously stated that linear switches are worse for typing than toggle switches since they take far less force to press the button, making it simpler to accidentally click and make typos. I stand by that statement.

But I must point you that not all linear switches are created equal, and I will explain why. When we think of linear switches, the first thing that comes to mind is usually red switches. In fact, these are by far the most widely used linear switches on the market. These, however, are not the only types of line switches.

In my previous considerations, I took into account the red switches from the most well-known manufacturers, such as Cherry, Gatheron, Outemu, or even Kalih, because these are the most commonly encountered switches.

However, as mechanical keyboards have gained in popularity, the variety of switches that are available has grown substantially. We will now be able to choose from a variety of various types of switches, each with its own set of performance characteristics.

When deciding to purchase linear switches, we have the option of selecting ones that are not as sensitive. Manufacturers are able to alter the amount of pressure required to activate the button by incorporating a different spring inside the switch.

In terms of the typing experience, I would recommend that you look into the black version of the linear switches, which is what I personally like. These switches are available from the majority of major manufacturers. Their work is distinguished by the fact that they must exert more pressure while typing, which reduces the likelihood of inadvertent errors occurring.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *